Constitutional Court Decision On Fingerprint Registration System Is Published! 26 April 2022
The Constitutional Court made a new decision regarding tracking employees' shifts by the employers in the working life, with fingerprint, face, palm, or retina scanning methods. The decision of the Constitutional Court, dated 10.03.2022, stating that tracking employees' shift with the fingerprint registration system violates the right to protection of personal data, was published in the Official Gazette dated 19 april 2022 and numbered 31814.
|
To summarize the flow of events; the applicant, who works as a civil servant in the Mayor's Office of Söke, applied to the institution, where he works, for the removal of the tracking shift with fingerprint registration system. Upon the rejection of the application by the institution, he filed a lawsuit in the Administrative Court for the removal of the aforementioned administrative action. |
|
The Administrative Court decided to accept the case and then, the institution appealed the decision. The District Administrative Court decided to dismiss with prejudice and accept the appeal. |
|
Then, the applicant applied to the Constitutional Court, claiming that his right to request the protection of his personal data within the scope of the right to respect to privacy has been violated due to the tracking employees' shift with the fingerprint registration system. |
|
Under Article 20 of the Constitution, personal data can be processed if it is stipulated by the law or if the data owner has consented explicitly. Concordantly, in Article 6 of the Law on Protection of Personal Data No. 6698 (“the Law”), some data groups are given a high-level of importance and they can only be processed if the data owner gives the explicit consent or if it is stipulated in another law explicitly. The Constitutional Court emphasized that for the consent to be given to be qualified as "explicit consent" it is necessary to inform the data owner in advance about the scope, purpose, limits, and consequences of the personal data to be processed; there must be a legitimate purpose for processing; there must be no other method for the aim of achieving the legitimate aim with less interference on the protection of personal data and the data should be processed finitely with the purpose. Therefore, it is underlined by the Constitutional Court that even if the processing of personal data is carried out based on the consent of the relevant person and the data is processed for a specific purpose, proceeding by obtaining explicit consent will not legitimize excessive collection of data and, in the light of the principle of proportionality, it will not be compatible with the principle of requesting minimum level data from the data subject. Thus, it has been clarified that the opinion of the Personal Data Protection Authority on this matter is in the same direction. |
|
When the Constitutional Court investigated the relevant legislation, it seems there is a provision for the administration to control the working hours of civil servants and the starting and ending times of daily working hours under the Civil Servants Law No. 657. However, there is no method regarding how to ensure this control. Similarly, in the Municipal Law No. 5393, the authority to conduct the municipal organization has been given to the mayor, but the scope of using this authority has not been determined. In this case, it is concluded that there is no explicit regulation in other laws regarding the processing of biometric data within the scope of tracking employees' shifts. |
|
So, the Constitutional Court decided that the right to request the protection of personal data within the scope of the right to respect to privacy was violated due to the processing of sensitive personal data by the administration without a legal basis, and showed its negative approach to processing of biometric data for purposes such as tracking shifts explicitly. |
|
You can find the full text of the decision at the link below: |
|
https://www.resmigazete.gov.tr/ eskiler/ 2022/ 04/ 20220419-7.pdf |
Other News
-
20.10.2025
Mergers and Acquisitions and the Notification Obligation within the Framework of Competition Law
Mergers and acquisitions (M&A) are at the center of the growth and restructuring strategies of companies. These transactions, serving the purpose of companies to expand both nationally and internationally to increase their market shares or to enter into new markets, not only give rise to economic and commercial consequences but also carry the potential to directly affect the competition dynamics in the relevant market. Therefore, merger and acquisition transactions may affect the competition structure in the market. In this respect, while M&A transactions create strategic opportunities, they are also among the areas carefully scrutinized by regulatory authorities to preserve competitive order.
-
17.10.2025
Important Amendment to the Organized Industrial Zones (OIZ) Implementation Regulation: Additional Time Granted To Participant
Published in the Official Gazette No. 33050, dated October 17, 2025, the "Regulation Amending the Organized Industrial Zones Implementation Regulation" introduces a new Provisional Article 13 to the existing regulation.This new provision allows OIZ participants who have not yet obtained a building permit or a workplace opening and operating license to apply for an extension period under certain conditions.
-
15.10.2025
Current Status Of The Obligation To Maintain Commercial Books In Electronic Form
1. INTRODUCTION With the Communiqué Amending the Communiqué on Keeping Commercial Books Not Related to the Accounting of the Enterprise in Electronic Form, published in the Official Gazette dated September 20, 2025 and numbered 33023 (“Amendment Communiqué”), significant amendments have been introduced to the Communiqué on Keeping Commercial Books Not Related to the Accounting of the Enterprise in Electronic Form, published in the Official Gazette dated February 14, 2025 and numbered 32813 (“Communiqué”).
-
25.9.2025
Social Security Procedures To Be Carried Out By The Employer Following A Reinstateme
Upon receiving notification of a final and binding reinstatement decision, if the employee communicates their intention to return to work within 10 business days, the employer may either reinstate the employee or refuse reinstatement by paying both the four months' idle period wages determined by the court and the compensation for non-reinstatement. As seen, the employer has two alternative courses of action in this situation; however, the procedures to be carried out before the Social Security Institution (SGK) differ in each case.
-
19.9.2025
The Court of Cassation has Ruled That The Competent Court Fot Cases Brought On The Grounds Of Volation Of The Non-Competition Clause Is The Commercial Court of First Instance
1. Introduction The duty not to compete is a type of loyalty obligation owed by the employee to the employer. The employee undertakes not to compete with the employer during the term of the employment contract as part of their loyalty obligation. However, Turkish law does not contain any legal provisions prohibiting the employee from competing with the employer after the employment contract has ended. However, the parties may freely agree that the employee will not compete with the employer after the termination of the employment contract. Articles 444-447 of the Turkish Code of Obligations also contain provisions and restrictions regarding non-competition agreements that may be established between the employee and the employer.
-
16.9.2025
Transfer Fee: Legal Characterization and Practical Application
1. Introduction The concept of a transfer fee is not directly defined in the Turkish Labor Code; its framework and legal nature in practice have largely been shaped by the decisions of the Court of Cassation (Turkey). This practice, which arises particularly in sectors with intense competition and limited skilled labor, is a type of payment that employers must carefully consider within the scope of their employment policies.
-
5.9.2025
Competition in the Labor Market: HR Practices to Avoid
The Turkish Competition Authority ("Authority"), which is entrusted with ensuring the proper functioning of markets, identifying practices that restrict competition, and imposing sanctions against infringements, operates under Law No. 4054 on the Protection of Competition ("Law") without distinction between input and output markets. Labor markets have recently emerged as one of the primary arenas in which entities compete in input markets and, with the influence of various additional dynamics, have become a market increasingly prioritized by the Authority. The Guidelines on Competition Violations in Labor Markets ("Guidelines"), adopted by the Authority on November 21, 2024, serve as an important reference for the prevention of competition infringements in labor markets. In this bulletin, in light of the Guidelines and decisions of the Competition Board ("Board") within the Authority, (i) the fundamental principles and information regarding the application of competition law to labor markets, and (ii) the main prohibited practices to be observed when competing in labor markets will be addressed.
-
29.8.2025
Does An Employee's Extended Period Of Sick Leave Grant The Employer The Right To Terminate The Emploment Contract?
In employer-employee relations, the direct impact of long-term medical reports on the status of the employment contract holds critical importance for both employees and employers. In particular, uninterrupted periods of sick leave lasting for a certain duration are regulated under Article 25/I(b) of the Labour Law as a specific provision that grants the employer the right to immediate termination for just cause and determines the rights to be granted to the employee. In this context, how the employer may exercise the right of termination for just cause following the employee's extended medical leave and the legal basis of this process should be examined in detail.
-
27.8.2025
Regulation On Direct Selling Was Published
The Regulation on Direct Selling ("Regulation"), issued by the Ministry of Trade ("Ministry") pursuant to Articles 47/A and 84 of the Consumer Protection Law No. 6502, was published in the Official Gazette dated 08.08.2025 and numbered 32980, thereby entering into force.
-
18.8.2025
SMS Verification Codes and the Personal Data Protection Board's Guideline Decision No. 2025/1072
The Personal Data Protection Board's Guideline Decision dated 10 June 2025 and numbered 2025/1072 introduces significant regulations regarding personal data processing activities conducted through SMS verification codes, which have become a widespread practice in commercial life. The decision requires significant adjustments to customer relationship management, particularly in the service and retail industries.
-
11.8.2025
Mergers And Acquisitions Of Companies Engaged In Renewable Energy Gereration
In recent years, notable developments in Turkey's electricity market have extended beyond investments aimed solely at increasing generation capacity. The sector has also come into focus through strategic investments and merger and acquisition (M&A) transactions involving companies operating in the field of renewable energy.
-
31.7.2025
Annual Leave, Severance Pay, and Notice Pay in Part - Time Employment Contracts
Part-Time Employment Contract Article 13 of the Labor Law No. 4857 defines a part-time employment contract as "a contract in which the employee's normal weekly working hours are significantly less than those of a full-time employee performing similar work."
-
30.7.2025
Legal Remedies And The Official Appeal Process For Property Tax Values
a. General Overview Following the enactment of Law No. 4751 in 2002, which amended the Tax Procedure Law, the Property Tax Law, and the Fees Law, the declaration-based system for determining the property tax base was abolished, and the tariff and assesment procedure implemented by administrative authorities was adopted.
-
25.7.2025
Labour Law No. 4857 Amended! Electronic Notification Opportunity Introduced With Rem
Article 109 of the Labour Law No. 4857 has been amended, together with its title and content, by the Law Amending the Law on the Protection of the Value of Turkish Currency and Certain Laws and the Decree Law No. 635 published in the Official Gazette dated 24 July 2025. With this important amendment, the procedures regarding the form of notifications to be made between employers and employees have been redefined.
-
16.7.2025
Terminatıon Right Of The Employer Due To Conviction And Detention And Legal Consequences
In labour law practice, which is a dynamic field based on the principle of protecting the balance between the employee and the employer, the employee's failure to fulfill their obligation to perform work-especially when this results from circumstances that restrict individual freedom, such as conviction or detention-has significant legal consequences regarding the termination of the employment contract.
