Responsibility Of Intermediary Service Provider For Defective Products Purchased Electronically. 07 February 2022
ON 15.11.2021, REGARDING THE LIABILITY OF THE SERVICE PROVIDER, 3rd LEGAL DEPARTMENT OF HIGH COURT DECIDED THAT THE INTERMEDIATE SERVICE PROVIDER IS NOT RESPONSIBLE FOR THE DEFICIENCY OF THE PRODUCTS WHICH ARE PURCHASED ELECTRONICALLY.

1. According to Article 2 of the Law on the Regulation of Electronical Commerce, which came into force on 01.05.2015, with the headline "Definitions" states that; service provider means 'Real or legal persons engaged in electronic commerce activities', intermediary service provider means 'real and legal persons who provide the electronic commerce environment for the economic and commercial activities of others'. In the decision, which is based on the examination of the responsibility attributed to real and legal persons defined within the scope of this law, after the purchasing of the product from the intermediary service provider's website the package was sent to the buyer by a registered "patisserie" of the site. Following the delivery, it was discovered that a cigarette butt came out from the package and accordingly, the responsibility for the defective product was examined. |
Today, it is obvious that commercial and daily life is gradually shifting towards the virtual environment. At this point, classifying the responsibility attributed for the products purchased over internet has become a difficult issue to dissect. In line with the developments, the work of legislators and related institutions carries crucial importance. The relevant event, which is the subject of our bulletin, has become even more critical due to the direction of today's understanding of consumption. |
In the concrete case, the plaintiff, who objected to the decision of the Esenler Consumer Arbitration Committee, stated that they have only mediated through the website where the plaintiff offered services to real or legal persons conducting sales activities. The defendant's application for a refund due to the defective product was accepted by the Consumer Arbitration Committee with the decision dated 20.03.2019 and numbered 056120190000723. The request of the intermediary institution, which objected to the decision regarding the refund, was rejected by the court of first degree. The reason for the refusal arises from the fact that the buyer receives service by relying on the name of the intermediary service provider. In the decision, the court further stated the basis for the refusal as the internal relationship between the plaintiff and the company providing the supply, thus, the issue of recourse is also not applicable since this relationship is subject to the internal affairs of the intermediary and the supplier. |
Following this, in the letter of the Ministry of Justice dated 17/03/2021; Although it is not possible to deal with the liability of the plaintiff company, which is not a seller, importer or manufacturer, but is a service provider to the consumer, in accordance with Articles 8 and the following, with the title of "Defective Goods" in the First Chapter of the Third Part of the Law on the Protection of the Consumer, It has been argued that the dismissal of the lawsuit on the grounds that the company is responsible for the services rendered due to commission received from the supplier company is contrary to the procedure and the law. |
All of the above-mentioned materials were evaluated by the High Court. The Court analyzed the issue that caused the dispute as the liability regarding the defect in the products purchased electronically and started its examinations accordingly. |
Evaluating the issue, the High Court first made analyzes within the framework of Article 13 of the Law on the Protection of the Consumer. According to the first paragraph of the relevant article, “Defective service is a service that is contrary to the contract because it does not start within the time specified in the contract or does not have the features that are agreed by the parties that it should have objectively.” Again, in accordance with Article 11 of the same Law, the responsibility of the seller, the manufacturer and the importer for the defective goods and the responsibility of the consumer for the optional rights are stated in this article. |
According to Article 2 of the Law on the Regulation of Electronic Commerce, which entered into force on 01.05.2015, in the title "Definitions", service provider means; 'Real or legal persons engaged in electronic commerce'. The intermediary service provider, which is defined in the continuation of the article, refers to the real and legal persons who provide the electronic commerce environment for the economic and commercial activities of others. |
Responsibility of Intermediary Service Providers, defined in Article 9 of the same law, is also stated in paragraph 4 of Article 6 of the same law as; “(4) The intermediary service provider is not obliged to check the content provided by real and legal persons using the electronic environment it provides services through, or to investigate whether there is an unlawful activity or situation related to this content and the goods or services subject to the content.” |
With this approach of the High Court, the responsibility automatically attributed to institutions that only act as intermediaries, and the obligation of recourse that arises accordingly, has been eliminated and a more direct causal link has been established between the parties. Thus, the 6th and 9th articles of the Law on the Regulation of Electronic Commerce were evaluated together and considering that the plaintiff, who is the intermediary service provider, is not responsible for the defective goods, a verdict has to be given for the acceptance of the case. The appeal request of the Ministry of Justice advocating regarding this aspect of the law has been accepted. |
As a result, with the decision taken, the approach of the Consumer Arbitration Committee, which holds the intermediary institutions directly responsible, was found to be faulty and the foundations for a more balanced regime between the Consumer and the Intermediary Institution were laid. Thanks to this approach of the Court of Cassation, institutions and organizations that carry out intermediary activities by receiving commissions on their own website are evaluated according to strict liability before the Arbitration Committees, and with this decision, the responsibility of the intermediary has been reduced and the responsibility relationship between the parties has been classified more clearly. |
Other News
-
26.4.2022
Constitutional Court Decision On Fingerprint Registration System Is Published!
The Constitutional Court made a new decision regarding tracking employees' shifts by the employers in the working life, with fingerprint, face, palm, or retina scanning methods. The decision of the Constitutional Court, dated 10.03.2022, stating that tracking employees' shift with the fingerprint registration system violates the right to protection of personal data, was published in the Official Gazette dated 19 april 2022 and numbered 31814.
-
25.4.2022
The Application Necessity Of Mediator In Negative Declaratory Actions!
The issue of the application necessity of mediator in terms of negative declaratory actions has been a matter of debate in doctrines and case-laws. However, at this point, a consensus has been reached on this issue and it is accepted that there is no application necessity of mediator in terms of negative declaratory actions.
-
20.4.2022
Amendment To The Currency Of Payment To Be Made In Foreign Exchange Indexed Sale Of Goods Contracts!
In accordance with the Decision No. 32 on the Protection of the Value of the Turkish Currency, the matters to be determined by the Ministry of Treasury and Finance are regulated by the "COMMUNIQUE REGARDING DECISION NO. 32 ON THE PROTECTION OF THE VALUE OF TURKISH CURRENCY (“the Communiqué”) (Communiqué No: 2008-32/34)".
-
19.4.2022
Charging Service Regulation Regarding Electric Vehicles Is Published!
In the context of the Charging Service Regulation (“Regulation”), published in the Official Gazette dated 02.04.2022 and numbered 31797, which entered into force on the date of its publication, the procedures and principles regarding the establishment of charging units and stations where electrical energy is supplied to electric vehicles, administration of stations connected to the charging network, provisions of charging service are determined. In this study, the main principles envisaged by the Regulation will be reviewed.
-
19.4.2022
Expected Guideline Regarding “Discounted Sales Advertisements” Has Been Released!
The regulation on 'discount sales advertisements', which has been regulated within the scope of the Law on the Protection of the Consumer, has been amended and this amendment entered into force on March 1, 2022. With this amendment,
-
4.4.2022
10 Most Frequently Asked Questions And Answers Regarding Foreigners To Legally Reside In Turkey
We have gathered the legal regulations regarding the "Presence of Foreigners in Turkey", which is the most frequently asked question by our clients, under the heading of 10 questions.
-
8.3.2022
Turnover Thresholds Based On Mergers And Acquisitions Subject To The Competition Board's Permission Have Changed!
An amendment was made to the Communiqué Concerning the Mergers and Acquisitions Calling for the Authorization of the Competition Board (“Communiqué No: 2010/4) with the Communiqué No. 2022/2 (“Communiqué on Amendment”) published in the Official Gazette dated 4 March, 2022 and numbered 31768.
-
24.2.2022
What Do Russian Sanctions Imply?
In terms of the possible effects of the crisis between Russia and Ukraine on commercial life, the statements made by the countries in the international community regarding this crisis are crucial. In this sense, Germany froze the approval process of the Nord Stream 2 gas line as a first step, while the USA banned trade with Luhansk and Donetsk. On the other hand, England froze the assets of five Russian banks and three Russian billionaires in the country, and Japan gave some sanction signals for the future. Finally, Canada announced that in the first phase of economic sanctions, Canadians were barred from financial agreements with Donetsk and Luhansk.
-
29.12.2021
Egemenoglu Advises Derindere Turizm Otomotiv Sanayi ve Ticaret A.S. on its Second Round of Consolidated and Syndicated Loan Restructuring
As Egemenoğlu Law Firm, we are pleased to announce that we have successfully concluded the second phase of the Financial Restructuring Project developed by our Restructuring Team, under the leadership of our Managing Partner Yunus Egemenoğlu, while we represented and advised Derindere Group, a pioneer in the fleet vehicle leasing industry of Turkey which was ranked, in 2019, as the 76th largest company by Turkey Fortune 500, with respect to the second round of the consolidated and syndicated loan restructuring of its debt amounting up to €350 million, held by numerous financial institutions (29, to be precise, including such giants as Credit Europe Bank, and Islamic Corporation for the Development of the Private Sector).
-
16.12.2021
The Regulation On Pollutant Emission And Transport Registration Is Published.
The “Regulation on Pollutant Emission and Transport Registration” (“Regulation”) prepared by the Ministry of Environment, Urbanization and Climate Change (“Ministry”) was published in the Official Gazette dated 4 December 2021. In the Regulation, the procedures and principles for the creation of a record of the emission and transport of pollutants are regulated in order to protect the environment and reduce environmental pollution originating from industrial and non-point sources.
-
14.12.2021
Procedures And Principles Regarding The Implementation Of Electronic Notification To Ssi Been Published, The Application Time
With the "Regulation Regarding Electronic Notification By Social Security Institution" (the Regulation), which published at the Official Gazette dated 24.09.2021 and numbered 31608, the e-notification period started in the Social Security Institution (SSI) and it was regulated that the documents required to be notified by the SSI would be notified to the addressees in electronic environment in accordance with the Regulation.
-
9.12.2021
Marital Property Rejimes And The Comparison Of The Right Of Contribution Claim And The Increased Value Claim
There are two basic marital property regime models in our law. The first of these is the separation of estates model. In this marital property regime model, spouses have the rights over the property they acquired during the marriage union on their own.
-
18.11.2021
Regulation on the Principles and Procedures of Fundraising Has Been Amended!
This article is prepared for informing about the amendments made in the "Regulation on the Principles and Procedures of Fundraising" (“the Regulation”). The amendments explained below are published in the Official Gazette dated 10.11.2021 and numbered 31655 and entered into force on the date of publication.
-
8.11.2021
The Deadline For The Cheque Presentation Ban Has Been Extended.
Numerous laws have been altered within the scope of The Law Amending the Law on the Establishment and Duties of the Turkish Exporters' Assembly and the Exporters' Associations and Certain Laws numbered 7341 (‘’The Law’’), which was published in the Official Gazette dated 06.11.2021 and numbered 31651. The law entered into force on the date of its publication. Along with this regulation, changes were made in the periods and dates cited in the temporal 3rd article of the Cheque Law No. 5941 and in the 543th Article of the Turkish Commercial Code Numbered 6102, titled "Distribution of Liquidation Result". In hereby this article, two main regulations introduced by the Law will be discussed.
-
27.10.2021
Regulation On The Amendment To The Associations Regulation Is Published!
Within the framework of The Regulation On The Amendment to The Associations Regulation (“Regulation”) published in the Official Gazette dated 21.10.2021 and numbered 31635, numerous amendments have been brought to the Associations Regulation published in the Official Gazette dated 31/03/2005 and numbered 25772. In this article, the main innovations introduced by the Regulation will be discussed.