SHOULD WE ANTICIPATE A FLOOD OF ADAPTATION LAWSUITS AND REFORMANTION, OF CONTRACTS? 13 April 2020
SHOULD WE ANTICIPATE A FLOOD OF ADAPTATION LAWSUITS AND REFORMANTION, OF CONTRACTS?
Many restrictive measures have been and are being taken both nationally and internationally in order to mitigate against the global “Coronavirus” (Covid-19) epidemic, which has been detected in almost all countries and continues to spread rapidly. Due to fact these restrictive measures impact commercial relations, business life and many contractual relationships directly, the status of these contracts and the legal relations between parties has started to be discussed and debated intensely.
These discussions and debates likely influence whether Coronavirus epidemic constitutes force majeure with respect to these contractual relationships, whether a failure by the parties to fulfill fully perform their contractual obligations due to the various national and international measures twill be considered a breach of their contract. In this context, we discuss below the subject of court adaptation or reformation of contractual obligations.
Before seeking a court adaptation of a contract, of course, , the parties are free to seek an agreement to amend their contracts to adapt to new circumstances, that is to agree to their own reformation without court intervention. If any such effort is unsuccessful, however, and certain conditions explained below exist, either party may request a judge to reform or adapt the contract to new circumstances, in other words, parties may file a lawsuit seeking to have the contract adapted or reformed.
Principles of “adherence to a contract (pacta sunt servanda)” and “freedom of contract” are cornerstones of Turkish contract law. As recognized by the Turkish Court of Appeal in well-established case-law, pursuant to these principles, the contract is to be performed according to its provisions at the time it was executed. In other words, even if new conditions arise making the performance of a party’s contractual obligations more difficult, the party is still obligated to perform as provided for in the contract, despite the new difficulties. In other words, the principle of adherence to a contract, as mentioned, constitutes one of the most fundamental principles of the law of contract, with the goal of providing predictability and certainty regarding the performance of contractual obligations, as well as encouraging the parties to act in good faith.This principle, however, is subject to certain limitations found in the private law.
The economic balance between the mutual performances existing when contract are executed may become unbalanced to the extent performance byone of the parties would result in a significant hardship for that party. In this case, abiding by the contract, and the principle of adherence to a contract, may result in unacceptable injustice or unfairness. In such a situation the principle of adherence to a contract gives way to the principle of “adapting the contract to changing circumstances”.
If changing circumstances circumvent the intent of a party or parties existing at the time a contract was executed, and the changes cause a situation strikingly and unpredictably unjust, the parties may be found to not be bound by the contract either wholly or in part. When faced with such changing circumstances, it may be necessary to seek reformation of the contract pursuant to Article 2 of the Turkish Civil Code.
Article 2 provides that in the case where extraordinary circumstances that: (i) were not reasonably foreseen, and were in fact not foreseen by parties at the time the contract was executed; and (ii) destroy the balance between mutual performances , making performance of contractual obligations by one or more of the parties significantly more difficult, provided the affected parties have not yet fulfilled the subject obligations or has fulfilled them with a reservation of rights, a judge may decide to require the performance in question for the benefit of the other party or may decide to excuse the affect parties from the obligations in question in full or in part and, in addition may reform or adapt the contract to take into consideration the extraordinary change of circumstances.
Adaptation lawsuits are most often seen in long-term, perpetual debt relationships. Adaptation in these situations, which is an exception of the principle of adherence to a contract, is addressed by Article 138 of the Turkish Code of Obligations under the title of "Hardship". According to this Article; “An extraordinary situation, which is not foreseen by the parties at the time of the contract and which was not anticipated by them, arises for a reason not due to the fault of the debtor and changes the existing facts at the time against the debtor in such a way as to violate the rules of good faith, then, if the debtor has not yet fulfilled his/her obligations due to the excessive difficulty of performance, the debtor shall have the right to request from the judge the adaptation of the contract to the new conditions and to revoke the contract if this is not possible. In contracts providing for continuing obligations, the debtor shall terminate the contract.”
One of the issues that need to be discussed given the current situation is possibility of bringing adaptation lawsuits, based on the “Coronavirus” (Covid-19) epidemic disease being an extraordinary situation a f unforeseen at the time contracts were signed by parties. For instance, “unpredictability” requirement for the adaptation of contracts signed before the virus had shown up in Turkey would be considered differently with regard tocontracts signed at the time the epidemic began to be seen in Turkey’s neighbouring countries in March 2020, and differently still when the virus started to be seen in Turkey. An argument that it was unforeseen by parties to a contract signed in, say, March 2020, when this epidemic had perhaps become the sole focus of the world, pushing even wars to the side, would not seem to be consistent with the requirement of good faith. We believe it likely experts would agree that the epidemic should be accepted as unforeseen for contracts signed prior to the time the virus showed up in Turkey or had become a global phenomenon.
To sum up, principles of “adherence to a contract” and “freedom of contract” are fundamental principles in Turkish law, pursuant to which a contract is to be performed as provided in it at the time it was executed, as has been settled by the case-law of the TurkishCourt of Appeal. That said, and although the measures imposed by the government have only covered a period of two to three months, if the, undeniably significant, effects of this epidemic continue, and even deepen, during this time and beyond, we expect experts will likely conclude these effects have deeply impacted the balance of the parties’ performances in long-term and perpetual contracts. For this reason, it may be that we will witness a flood of adaptation lawsuits in the upcoming weeks and months, assuming the other conditions set forth Article 138 of Turkish Code of Obligations and Article 2 of the Turkish Civil Code are present.
More particularly, for a judge to decide to adapt a contract due to “Coronavirus” (Covid-19), the following conditions must be satisfied:
- The balance between the performances of the parties to the contract should have become unbalanced to such an extent that one of the parties cannot be expected to perform some or all of its contractual obligations.
- The change in the balance between performances should arise from extraordinary reasons which were not and could not have been foreseen when contract was executed.
- The circumstances that cause the hardship should not be the fault of the party seeking adaption.
The party seeking adaptation should either not yet have fulfilled the obligation sought to be adapted or, if the party has fulfilled the obligation, it did so while reserving its rights given the excessive difficulty of the performance.
Other News
-
15.3.2024
New Regulations Introduced With The 8th Judicial Package
The Law No. 7499 on the Amendment of the Code of Criminal Procedure and Certain Laws ("Law"), which contains amendments and new regulations known as the "8th Judicial Package", was published in the Official Gazette dated 12 March 2024 and numbered 32487. In this article, we will discuss the amendments to the Criminal Procedure Code No. 5271 (" CPC"), Turkish Criminal Code No. 5237 ("TCC"), Turkish Civil Code No. 4721 ("TCC"), Enforcement and Bankruptcy Code No. 2004 ("EBC") and Law No. 6384 on the Duties and Working Procedures and Principles of the Compensation Commission.
-
12.3.2024
Changes In The PDPL Was Published In THE Official Gazette
Law No. 7499 on Amendments to the Code of Criminal Procedure and Some Laws ("Law No. 7499") including critical amendments to the Law No. 6698 on the Personal Data Protection Law ("PDPL") was published in the Official Gazette on March 12, 2024.
-
9.2.2024
Amendments Were Made To The Regulations Based On The Occupational Health And Safety Law
In the Official Gazette dated 4 February 2024 and numbered 32450, amendments were made to some regulations issued based on the Occupational Health and Safety Law No. 6331:
-
1.2.2024
Turkish Competition Board Mergers And Acquisitions Outlook Report For 2023 Has Been Published
On January 5th, 2024, the Turkish Competition Authority has published the Report prepared by the Competition Board on Mergers, Acquisitions And Privatisation Transactions in 2023 ("Report").
-
31.1.2024
Important Principle Decision From The Advertising Board Regarding Discount Sale Advertisements
At the first meeting of the year held on January 9, 2024, the Advertising Board made an important principle decision regarding discount sale advertisements by amending the "Guideline on Advertisements Containing Price Information and Discount Sale Advertisements and Commercial Practices" in order to prevent consumer victimization through misleading advertisements and practices that lead to unfair competition in the retail trade sector.
-
17.1.2024
The Authority to Decide on Trademark Cancellation Passed to the Turkish Patent And Trademark Office!
In Article 192/1 (a) of the Industrial Property Law ("IPL") published in the Official Gazette dated 10 January 2017 and numbered 29944, the enforcement of Article 26 of the Law titled "Cancellation Cases and Cancellation Request" was postponed until seven years later, and with the Provisional Article 4 of the IPL, it was stipulated that the authority to decide on the cancellation of trademarks would be directly exercised by the Intellectual and Industrial Rights Civil Courts until 10 January 2024.
-
16.1.2024
Egemenoğlu Hukuk Bürosu / Internship Application
We are pleased to announce the opening of internship applications at Egemenoğlu Hukuk Bürosu. Legal Internship Application Deadline: March 15 Summer Internship Application Deadline: March 29 Prospective candidates are requested to submit their CVs either through our website www.egemenoglu.av.tr or by sending them to info@egemenoglu.av.tr.
-
12.1.2024
Turkish Sustainability Reporting Standards (TSRS) And Scope Of Application Of TSRSs Were Puslished In The Official Gazette
In the Official Gazette dated 29.12.2023 and numbered 32414, the Public Oversight, Accounting and Auditing Standards Authority (POA) announced the Turkish Sustainability Reporting Standards and determined the principles to be followed in sustainability reports.
-
11.1.2024
Important Regulations Which Are Effective As Of 2024 And/ Or Has Been Made Subject To Time Extension
Laws No. 5746 and No. 6550 extended the regulation on higher depreciation (showing expenses related to depreciation) and calculation rates and periods for new machines acquired for use in R&D, innovation and design activities.
-
19.12.2023
The Principles and Rules to be Applied in Retail Trade have been reorganize
With the "Regulation Amending the Regulation on Principles and Rules to be Applied in Retail Trade" prepared by the Ministry of Commerce and published in the official gazette on 14.12.2023, significant changes were made in the principles and rules of retail trade.
-
18.11.2023
Warning From The Authority On Sending Verification Codes To Customers Via Sms During Shopping
The Personal Data Protection Authority ("Authority") published a Public Announcement ("Announcement") on the Processing of Personal Data by Sending a Verification Code via SMS to the Data Subjects during Shopping in Stores.
-
14.11.2023
Communiqué Amending the Communiqué on the Procedures and Principles Regarding the Application of Article 376 of the Turkish Commercial Code No. 6102 has been published
In order to regulate the procedures and principles to be followed in cases of loss of capital or insolvency of joint stock companies, limited liability companies and limited partnership companies with capital divided into shares within the scope of Article 376 of the Turkish Commercial Code No. 6102 (Law), the Communiqué on the Procedures and Principles Regarding the Application of Article 376 of the Turkish Commercial Code No. 6102 (Communiqué) was first published in the Official Gazette dated 15/09/2018 and numbered 30536, and with the Provisional Article 1 of this Communiqué until 01/01/2023, Within the scope of Article 376 of the Law, it was stated that foreign exchange losses arising from foreign currency denominated liabilities that have not yet been fulfilled may not be taken into account in the calculations regarding capital loss or insolvency.
-
3.11.2023
Law No. 7464 on the Leasing of Houses For Tourism Purposes And Amendment To Certain Laws Has Been Published
Published in the Official Gazette dated 2.11.2023 and numbered 32357 and published in the Official Gazette dated 2.11.2023 and numbered 32357, the Law on the Leasing of Houses for Tourism Purposes and Amendments to Certain Laws (No: 7464) aims to determine the procedures and principles regarding the leasing of houses to real and legal persons for tourism purposes.
-
28.10.2023
Partial Payment Period In Pension: Regulation On Partial Payment In The Private Pension System Has Been Published
With the amendment made to the Private Pension Savings and Investment System Law on 19.01.2022, a regulation was introduced stipulating that the participant can be partially paid up to fifty percent of the accumulation amount in his account, excluding the amounts in the State contribution account, without leaving the system, in cases and conditions determined by the Insurance and Private Pension Regulation and Supervision Agency. In this case, payments can also be made from the amount in the State contribution account, not exceeding twenty-five percent of the partial payment amount and the principles and procedures regarding the transactions to be carried out within this scope, including the practices regarding the State contribution, will be determined by the Institution with the appropriate opinion of the Ministry and with the amendment dated 19.01.2022, the relevant regulation is included in the Individual Pension Savings and Investment System Law.
-
9.9.2023
Focus On Digital And Green Transformation: Türkiye's Medium - Term Program Published.
The Medium-Term Program (2024-2026), prepared by the Ministry of Treasury and Finance and the Presidency of Strategy and Budget, was approved and published in Official Gazette No. 32301 dated September 6th, 2023.