THE LIMITS OF UNFAIR COMPETITION BY DENIGRATING UNDER THE LIGHT OF THE JUDGEMENT OF THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY OF CIVIL CHAMBERS OF SUPREME COURT 09 January 2021

Unfair competition refers to all behaviors and practices that violate the integrity rule of the parties of the economic order and distort competition against one party. For the existence of unfair competition, it is not obligatory for the parties to be competitors, or the perpetrator to benefit from unfair competition or the perpetrator has been at fault. What is essential for the existence of unfair competition; is the use of the economic competition right contrary to the good faith. |
Rules of unfair competition are regulated under Article 54 to 63 of Turkish Commercial Code No 6102. The Article 54 of Turkish Commercial Code titled “purpose and principle” sets out the general principle of unfair competition. According to this: “behaviors or practices that are of deceptive nature or in violation with the principle of good faith between commercial rivals or suppliers and customers are qualified unjust and illegal”. In the continuation of this general principle, some unfair competition actions that are frequently encountered in practice and that are against the good faith are listed. |
It is unfair competition “to denigrate others or their goods, business products, prices, activities or business affairs with false, misleading or unnecessarily offensive statements” according to Article 55/1-a of Turkish Commercial Code No 6102. The term "denigration" here, in general terms, refers to behaviors that will create a negative impression of a person's commercial life. As it can be understood from the text of the article, in order for unfair competition to occur within the scope of such article, it is necessary to disparage the activities of others with unnecessarily offensive statements. According to the justification of the Article, denigration includes defamation, obscuring, belittling and dropping its value according to the concrete event. Therefore defamation, obscuring or belittling others or their goods, business products, prices, activities or business affairs is considered within the scope of "denigration". In order for the declaration of denigration to constitute unfair competition; this declaration should be made with false, misleading or unnecessarily offensive explanations. First of all, the main issue sought is that the statement to be "delusive". In other words, if the statements are true, it shall not be taken into consideration within the scope of unfair competition. The current case law of the Supreme Court has been reached a consensus in such a way that there is no room for hesitation to unfair competition be mentioned if the statement is true. |
As it stated at The Judgement of General Assembly of Civil Chambers of Supreme Court dated 10/06/2020, numbered 2017/39 E. and 2020/396 K.: in order for the "denigration" in the article to be qualified as "unfair competition", first there must be a statement, it must be about personality, property, work products, activities or commercial affairs of others; and finally, this statement must be false, misleading or unnecessarily offensive. False statement is a statement that content is incompatible with the truth, and that content is objectively incorrect about a particular fact or event or situation. Misleading statements are statements that, when evaluated together with their nature, style and content, may cause the addressee of the statement to fall into error and make a false impression on them. And an unnecessarily hurtful statement which exceeds its purpose by creating a negative impression about a person, his/her activities, work products etc. and create a negative impression about while being accurate in its content. (Suluk, Cahit / Karasu, Rauf / Nal, Temel: Fikri Mülkiyet Hukuku, Ankara, 2017, s.428) |
The only criterion for determining whether the statement is "false" is whether it is compatible with reality. If the statement is accurate, then unfair competition cannot be mentioned. On the other hand, the criterion to be used for determining whether the statement is "misleading" or "unnecessarily hurtful" is the usual medium-skilled addressee of the statement. |
In other words, whichever group the statement is made to, the mode of understanding of a person of medium ability belonging to that group will be taken as basis. Therefore, the way that the explanation is perceived by the average addressee is important not how the statement is perceived by a particular person or persons. (Ülgen, Hüseyin / Helvacı, Mehmet / Kendigelen, Abuzer / Kaya, Aslan / Nomer Ertan, Füsun: Ticari İşletme Hukuku, İstanbul, 2015, s. 540) |
In the dispute subject to the decision of the General Assembly of Civil Chambers of Supreme Court dated 10/06/2020, numbered 2017/39 E. and 2020/396 K.; the plaintiff has claimed that the plaintiff has purchased a port crane from the defendant company and spare parts service from the other defendant to this crane, and that although any service has not been requested from the defendant it has been notified to plaintiff that the cylinder of the crane is ultrasound checked and needs to be replaced immediately and that the crane’s guarantee term has expired, and upon this the plaintiff got a report by a private company that there were no cracks on the cylinder, despite this the defendants has reported that the cylinder is cracked to the Port Authority, and that it is unfair competition that the defendants to report the crane is cracked to the Port Authority although there is not such a malfunction; and demanded the defendants’ actions to be determined as unfair competition, and to be prohibited, the district court has partially accepted the case on the grounds that the action damaged the commercial reputation of the plaintiff and caused unfair competition, the parties appealed the decision, all appeals of the parties has been rejected and the decision has been approved. |
The defendant's attorney has requested a correction of the decision. The 11th Civil Chamber of the Supreme Court stated that in the expert report taken by the district court during the trial that it has been clearly determined that there has a crack in the hydraulic cylinder as a result of the measurements made by two separate ultrasound devices. Thereupon, it has been decided by the high court that it is not possible that the defendants' warnings of security to the company which the plaintiff is doing business to be considered as disparaging their commodity, work product, activity or commercial affairs with false, misleading or unnecessary statements. For this reason, contrary to the acceptance of the district court, the high court overturned the decision of the district court by finding it wrong that the decision of the acceptance of the case with a wrong evaluation in writing, while it has been necessary to dismiss the case, although there was no false, misleading or offensive statement about the plaintiff in terms of the content of the letter written by the defendant party to the port operator. |
The district court resisted in its decision for previous reasons, and the dispute has been transferred to the Supreme Court Legal General Assembly. |
The General Assembly of the Supreme Court, decided that the notification subject to the case did not constitute unfair competition on the grounds that "because of the fact that it is detected by the experts that there is a crack on the cylinder of the crane; giving a security warning to the Port Authority by the defendants cannot be determined as denigrating personality or goods, business products, activities or business affairs of the plaintiff with false, misleading or unnecessarily offensive statements, since it is established that the statements of the defendants are not false, it is understood that this statement is not misleading or unnecessarily offensive. |
As can be clearly seen in the aforementioned decision, the accuracy of the statement subject to unfair competition has been taken as basis; it was emphasized that the notification made regarding the problem occurring during the execution of the contractual relationship between the parties cannot be described as defamation of the plaintiff's personality, commodity, work product, activity or commercial affairs with false, misleading or unnecessary statements. Therefore, reporting a defect, error or dysfunction related to a good or service to the relevant third parties with correct content cannot be considered within the scope of unfair competition. |
Other News
-
5.9.2025
Competition in the Labor Market: HR Practices to Avoid
The Turkish Competition Authority ("Authority"), which is entrusted with ensuring the proper functioning of markets, identifying practices that restrict competition, and imposing sanctions against infringements, operates under Law No. 4054 on the Protection of Competition ("Law") without distinction between input and output markets. Labor markets have recently emerged as one of the primary arenas in which entities compete in input markets and, with the influence of various additional dynamics, have become a market increasingly prioritized by the Authority. The Guidelines on Competition Violations in Labor Markets ("Guidelines"), adopted by the Authority on November 21, 2024, serve as an important reference for the prevention of competition infringements in labor markets. In this bulletin, in light of the Guidelines and decisions of the Competition Board ("Board") within the Authority, (i) the fundamental principles and information regarding the application of competition law to labor markets, and (ii) the main prohibited practices to be observed when competing in labor markets will be addressed.
-
29.8.2025
Does An Employee's Extended Period Of Sick Leave Grant The Employer The Right To Terminate The Emploment Contract?
In employer-employee relations, the direct impact of long-term medical reports on the status of the employment contract holds critical importance for both employees and employers. In particular, uninterrupted periods of sick leave lasting for a certain duration are regulated under Article 25/I(b) of the Labour Law as a specific provision that grants the employer the right to immediate termination for just cause and determines the rights to be granted to the employee. In this context, how the employer may exercise the right of termination for just cause following the employee's extended medical leave and the legal basis of this process should be examined in detail.
-
27.8.2025
Regulation On Direct Selling Was Published
The Regulation on Direct Selling ("Regulation"), issued by the Ministry of Trade ("Ministry") pursuant to Articles 47/A and 84 of the Consumer Protection Law No. 6502, was published in the Official Gazette dated 08.08.2025 and numbered 32980, thereby entering into force.
-
18.8.2025
SMS Verification Codes and the Personal Data Protection Board's Guideline Decision No. 2025/1072
The Personal Data Protection Board's Guideline Decision dated 10 June 2025 and numbered 2025/1072 introduces significant regulations regarding personal data processing activities conducted through SMS verification codes, which have become a widespread practice in commercial life. The decision requires significant adjustments to customer relationship management, particularly in the service and retail industries.
-
11.8.2025
Mergers And Acquisitions Of Companies Engaged In Renewable Energy Gereration
In recent years, notable developments in Turkey's electricity market have extended beyond investments aimed solely at increasing generation capacity. The sector has also come into focus through strategic investments and merger and acquisition (M&A) transactions involving companies operating in the field of renewable energy.
-
31.7.2025
Annual Leave, Severance Pay, and Notice Pay in Part - Time Employment Contracts
Part-Time Employment Contract Article 13 of the Labor Law No. 4857 defines a part-time employment contract as "a contract in which the employee's normal weekly working hours are significantly less than those of a full-time employee performing similar work."
-
30.7.2025
Legal Remedies And The Official Appeal Process For Property Tax Values
a. General Overview Following the enactment of Law No. 4751 in 2002, which amended the Tax Procedure Law, the Property Tax Law, and the Fees Law, the declaration-based system for determining the property tax base was abolished, and the tariff and assesment procedure implemented by administrative authorities was adopted.
-
25.7.2025
Labour Law No. 4857 Amended! Electronic Notification Opportunity Introduced With Rem
Article 109 of the Labour Law No. 4857 has been amended, together with its title and content, by the Law Amending the Law on the Protection of the Value of Turkish Currency and Certain Laws and the Decree Law No. 635 published in the Official Gazette dated 24 July 2025. With this important amendment, the procedures regarding the form of notifications to be made between employers and employees have been redefined.
-
16.7.2025
Terminatıon Right Of The Employer Due To Conviction And Detention And Legal Consequences
In labour law practice, which is a dynamic field based on the principle of protecting the balance between the employee and the employer, the employee's failure to fulfill their obligation to perform work-especially when this results from circumstances that restrict individual freedom, such as conviction or detention-has significant legal consequences regarding the termination of the employment contract.
-
14.7.2025
Radical Change In The Labor Law Dated 14.07.2025: Flexible Week Holiday Period Has Started In The Tourism Sector!
With the Law No. 7553 on the "Amendment of Certain Laws and Decree Law No. 375" published in the Official Gazette on July 14, 2025, important innovations have been introduced in the Labor Law and some other laws. In this context; as of 14.07.2025, with the provision added to the article Article 46 of the Labor Law which regulates the week holiday, flexible week holiday specific to the tourism sector have been introduced.
-
9.7.2025
Climate Law Enacted
The Climate Law No. 7552 ("Law"), which includes regulations on the procedures and principles related to the reduction of greenhouse gas emissions in the fight against climate change, climate adaptation activities, planning and implementation tools, revenues, permits and inspections, and the legal and institutional framework surrounding these, was published in the Official Gazette dated July 9, 2025, No. 32951, and entered into force. This Law sets out general principles and objectives from a casuistic perspective, preferring to leave detailed and technical regulations to secondary legislation.
-
7.7.2025
Mediation Practices In The Land Registry
Pursuant to the amendments introduced by Law on Amendments to the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law and to Certain Other Laws which was published in the Official Gazette dated 05.04.2023, numbered 32154 to the Law on Mediation in Civil Disputes dated 7/6/2012 and numbered 6325 ("Law"), the scope of disputes that may be resolved through procedural- mandatory- and voluntary mediation has been expanded.
-
27.6.2025
Effects Of The Concordatum Period On Pledgees
Pursuant to Article 285 of the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law (EBL), a debtor who is unable to pay their debts on time or is at risk of default may request a concordatum. During the period granted to the debtor upon such request, no enforcement proceedings may be initiated, and ongoing proceedings are suspended, in accordance with Article 294/1 of the EBL.
-
18.6.2025
M&A Dynamics in Publicly Traded Companies: New Investment Strategies Through Borsa Istanbul
In recent years, IPOs in Turkey have reached record levels. In 2023 and 2024, a large number of companies started trading in Borsa Istanbul as a result of initial public offerings (IPO) transactions. These IPOs, which attracted great interest from small investors, stand out as important strategic moves in which companies gain transparency and visibility, and also play a role as an important financing tool. With IPOs, publicly traded companies / partnerships are now drawing the attention of not only small investors but also domestic/foreign strategic and financial investors.
-
16.6.2025
The Court Of Cassation Abandoned Its Long-Standing Precedent Regarding Construction Conracts In Return For Land Shares, Known As "Advance Deed"
Construction contracts in return for land shares are a common practice in the construction sector in Turkey.